Tim Bray heard the presidential debates in terms of marketing strategy.
Bush adopted a positional strategy. Stick to the message (a message he inherited from his father, along with a number of messengers). Consistency is everything. Repetition is better than hesitation; hesitation better than deviation.
In contrast, Kerry apparently follows a relational strategy.
Monday, October 04, 2004
Friday, July 16, 2004
Dialog on Leadership
This is a great website.
Claus Otto Scharmer of Generon Consulting and MIT has done a series of interviews with some extraordinarily inspired leaders. Joe Jaworski, Peter Senge, Lucy Suchman, Francisco Varela, and many more.
The interviews are illustrated by a series of paintings by Andrew Campbell FRA.
Claus Otto Scharmer of Generon Consulting and MIT has done a series of interviews with some extraordinarily inspired leaders. Joe Jaworski, Peter Senge, Lucy Suchman, Francisco Varela, and many more.
The interviews are illustrated by a series of paintings by Andrew Campbell FRA.
Thursday, July 15, 2004
Brutality and Public Service
Will Hutton, Is Gordon ready to be brutal? Plans to slim down the civil service demand a management revolution The Guardian, July 14, 2004 [update: URL corrected]
Hutton uses this article to give a plug for a report from his own organization, the Work Foundation.
David Coats, Efficiency, Efficiency, Efficiency The Gershon Review: Public Service Efficiency and the Management of Change (pdf 150kb)
The Work Foundation paper seeks to downplay Choice, and replace it with some notion of Public Value. Does this mean that old-fashioned civil servants (Sir Humphrey, Lord Butler) know best? From the supply side, Efficiency appears to be in conflict with Choice.
But when we look at the situation from the demand side, there is no conflict at all - indeed, you can only achieve true efficiency by personalization and choice. The Prime Minister and the Chancellor both seem to understand this, but they are surrounded by people with a vested interest in the status quo.
Technorati Tags: choice efficiency
Hutton uses this article to give a plug for a report from his own organization, the Work Foundation.
David Coats, Efficiency, Efficiency, Efficiency The Gershon Review: Public Service Efficiency and the Management of Change (pdf 150kb)
The Work Foundation paper seeks to downplay Choice, and replace it with some notion of Public Value. Does this mean that old-fashioned civil servants (Sir Humphrey, Lord Butler) know best? From the supply side, Efficiency appears to be in conflict with Choice.
But when we look at the situation from the demand side, there is no conflict at all - indeed, you can only achieve true efficiency by personalization and choice. The Prime Minister and the Chancellor both seem to understand this, but they are surrounded by people with a vested interest in the status quo.
Technorati Tags: choice efficiency
Wednesday, July 14, 2004
Jimmy Carter
In my post on Ronald Reagan, I referred to Jimmy Carter as bright. Donella Meadows praises his grasp of systems thinking.
What to do when systems resist change; an excerpt from Donella Meadows's unfinished last book.
But it's a real problem for a leader if he can't explain his ideas, and can't get them implemented.
President Jimmy Carter had an unusual ability to think in feedback terms and to make feedback policies. Unfortunately he had a hard time explaining them to a press and public that didn't understand feedback.
What to do when systems resist change; an excerpt from Donella Meadows's unfinished last book.
But it's a real problem for a leader if he can't explain his ideas, and can't get them implemented.
Friday, June 18, 2004
Transference and Counter-Transference
Transference
Within psychoanalytic theory, there has been a great deal written about the phenomenon of transference, where the client uses the relationship with the therapist to replace something else, and becomes as it were addicted to the therapy/therapist.A related phenomenon also occurs with management consultancy.
Counter-Transference
Counter-Transference refers to the phenomenon where the analyst or consultant picks up feelings that are relevant to the interaction with the client.An inexperienced analyst or consultant may allow these feelings to interfere with the consultation.
An experienced analyst or consultant may be able to use these feelings as useful pointers towards What Is Going On.
Transitional Objects
"Interestingly, consultants and other change agents often become transitional objects for their client firms: The client refuses to ‘let go’, and becomes crucially dependent on the change agent’s advice in relation to every move." [Morgan]"In helping to facilitate any kind of social change it may thus be necessary for the change agent to create transitional phenomena when they do not exist naturally. Just as father or mother may have to help their child find a substitute for Teddy, a change agent - whether a social revolutionary or a paid consultant - must usually help his or her target group to relinquish what is held dear before they can move on. Significantly, this can rarely be done effectively by ‘selling’ or imposing a ‘change package’, an ideology or a set of techniques. The theory of transitional phenomena suggests that in situations of voluntary change, the person doing the changing must be in control of the process. … If the change agent tries to bypass or suppress what is valued, it is almost sure to resurface at a later date." [Morgan]
Links
Saturday, June 12, 2004
Leadership and Renunciation
Web searching for Leadership and Renunciation, I got lots of spiritual stuff. Plus commentary on Sonia Gandhi renouncing leadership.
Buddhist Leadership
Renunciation/Affirmation - A Vaisnava-Christian Dialogue
Price of Leadership: Emulation and Envy
S Leelavathi, India Times
Web searching for Burning Ones Bridges, I find lots of material advising against it. Web consensus (thanks to Google) is to leave your options open But then Google merely leads us into thinking with the majority.
The emphasis here is on what the leader renounces for himself or herself - including leadership itself. But my interest is on what the leader renounces on behalf of the group - deliberately closing down options in order to increase the focus and commitment of the group.
Buddhist Leadership
Renunciation/Affirmation - A Vaisnava-Christian Dialogue
Price of Leadership: Emulation and Envy
S Leelavathi, India Times
Web searching for Burning Ones Bridges, I find lots of material advising against it. Web consensus (thanks to Google) is to leave your options open But then Google merely leads us into thinking with the majority.
The emphasis here is on what the leader renounces for himself or herself - including leadership itself. But my interest is on what the leader renounces on behalf of the group - deliberately closing down options in order to increase the focus and commitment of the group.
Ronald Reagan
Today America has been celebrating the life and works of its 40th president.
Some recent presidents and would-be presidents have been remarkable intelligent. Richard Nixon was bright, effective in many areas, but brought down by flaws in his character. Jimmy Carter was if anything even brighter, with a strong and visible moral code which his predecessors apparently lacked, and yet was completely ineffective as president. In contrast, Ford was often scorned for his lack of intellect.
Reagan changed the equation. He is widely seen as having achieved more in foreign policy than Nixon. His evident lack of intellect, although causing some derision in European circles, only seemed to enhance his standing in America.
Following Reagan, the intelligent thing seems to be to hide your intelligence. Bill Clinton was intelligent but didn't show it. In contrast, George Bush senior and Al Gore presented themselves as intelligent - which was perhaps evidence that they weren't intelligent enough - and were rejected at the polls. George Bush junior is clearly not as unintelligent as many people think he is, but he has learned the Reagan lesson well.
In American history, the preference for Character over Intelligence goes back to Washington.
Some recent presidents and would-be presidents have been remarkable intelligent. Richard Nixon was bright, effective in many areas, but brought down by flaws in his character. Jimmy Carter was if anything even brighter, with a strong and visible moral code which his predecessors apparently lacked, and yet was completely ineffective as president. In contrast, Ford was often scorned for his lack of intellect.
Reagan changed the equation. He is widely seen as having achieved more in foreign policy than Nixon. His evident lack of intellect, although causing some derision in European circles, only seemed to enhance his standing in America.
Following Reagan, the intelligent thing seems to be to hide your intelligence. Bill Clinton was intelligent but didn't show it. In contrast, George Bush senior and Al Gore presented themselves as intelligent - which was perhaps evidence that they weren't intelligent enough - and were rejected at the polls. George Bush junior is clearly not as unintelligent as many people think he is, but he has learned the Reagan lesson well.
In American history, the preference for Character over Intelligence goes back to Washington.
Saturday, January 24, 2004
Choice and action
Aidan rightly indicates that leadership often involves generating new choices for the people and organizations under this leadership.
However, we can sometimes be paralysed by too many choices. And in the consumer society we may have the illusion of choice.
Leadership also involves the renunciation of certain choices. Making commitments, burning your bridges. Perhaps this is what Aidan means by discipline, but I think that word sounds too static.
However, we can sometimes be paralysed by too many choices. And in the consumer society we may have the illusion of choice.
Leadership also involves the renunciation of certain choices. Making commitments, burning your bridges. Perhaps this is what Aidan means by discipline, but I think that word sounds too static.
Friday, January 02, 2004
Leadership and Holes
We sometimes talk as if there is a leader-shaped hole at the top of each organization. Not all organizations have the same leadership requirements of course, but for each organization, there is a search for a leader who perfectly fits the leader-shaped hole.
Sometimes existing managers swell in importance to fill the hole, like balloons inflated in a small box. Sometimes a manager is recruited from elsewhere, and must be partially deflated before being stuffed into the box and pumped up again.
But such a leader is too tightly stuffed into the job to make any real changes. Surely this is not genuine leadership.
Sometimes existing managers swell in importance to fill the hole, like balloons inflated in a small box. Sometimes a manager is recruited from elsewhere, and must be partially deflated before being stuffed into the box and pumped up again.
But such a leader is too tightly stuffed into the job to make any real changes. Surely this is not genuine leadership.
Tuesday, December 23, 2003
Awareness and Prediction
Aidan asks - do we want self-aware organisations or would we rather they stayed in a more predictable place?
Who then are the stakeholders for awareness and self-awareness? Who are the stakeholders for prediction and predictability?
There are clearly worlds in which these goals conflict to some extent. Meanwhile, there are worlds in which they are complementary.
When we inhabit a world with conflicting goals, should we expect our leaders to show us the way to a world where these goals can be reconciled?
Who then are the stakeholders for awareness and self-awareness? Who are the stakeholders for prediction and predictability?
There are clearly worlds in which these goals conflict to some extent. Meanwhile, there are worlds in which they are complementary.
When we inhabit a world with conflicting goals, should we expect our leaders to show us the way to a world where these goals can be reconciled?
Leadership and Simplicity
Leaders (both in business and politics) often insist on a simple view of the world. They adopt patterns of thought (such as either/or thinking) that more complex thinkers regard with suspicion or even contempt. Strong foreground issues are sketched against the vaguest possible background. For their part, leaders often impatiently dismiss more complex or precise reasoning, perhaps seeing it as a symptom of resistance to action and change.
There are two possible explanations for this phenomenon. The first is that leaders actually do have a strong and simple picture of the world. This may even be one of the characteristics that qualifies a person for leadership.
The second explanation is that part of the leadership task is the construction and propagation of a sufficiently strong and simple picture of the world to carry people and organizations forward. Perhaps some leaders privately cherish more complex and nuanced pictures of the world, but they believe it to be tactically unwise to share these complexities with the public, and discourage their immediate followers from discussing them. They may even practise the kind of mental self-discipline that suppresses their own doubts – thus edging us back into Explanation One.
In his last post, Aidan talks about leaders speaking only of measures and numbers. This may be part of the same phenomenon – the leaders only talk about what they are confident their followers and public can both understand and enact. Meanwhile, leadership is often only granted to those who are trusted to operate in predictable (low-level?) ways.
Fortunate indeed are the leaders whose followers and public can understand and enact more challenging material, such as purposes and values. Of course some wise and brave leaders may have a private intention to raise the level at which their followers and public can understand and act.
However, there are obvious difficulties to communicating such intentions in advance, except in the vaguest terms. A trusted leader may be given some licence to take an organization into unknown territory, but what if the trust is used up before the objectives are reached?
If we want to appreciate leadership, then, we need to pay attention not just to what leaders say, but also to what they do – inferring as much as possible from the behaviour of the systems these leaders inhabit.
There are two possible explanations for this phenomenon. The first is that leaders actually do have a strong and simple picture of the world. This may even be one of the characteristics that qualifies a person for leadership.
The second explanation is that part of the leadership task is the construction and propagation of a sufficiently strong and simple picture of the world to carry people and organizations forward. Perhaps some leaders privately cherish more complex and nuanced pictures of the world, but they believe it to be tactically unwise to share these complexities with the public, and discourage their immediate followers from discussing them. They may even practise the kind of mental self-discipline that suppresses their own doubts – thus edging us back into Explanation One.
In his last post, Aidan talks about leaders speaking only of measures and numbers. This may be part of the same phenomenon – the leaders only talk about what they are confident their followers and public can both understand and enact. Meanwhile, leadership is often only granted to those who are trusted to operate in predictable (low-level?) ways.
Fortunate indeed are the leaders whose followers and public can understand and enact more challenging material, such as purposes and values. Of course some wise and brave leaders may have a private intention to raise the level at which their followers and public can understand and act.
However, there are obvious difficulties to communicating such intentions in advance, except in the vaguest terms. A trusted leader may be given some licence to take an organization into unknown territory, but what if the trust is used up before the objectives are reached?
If we want to appreciate leadership, then, we need to pay attention not just to what leaders say, but also to what they do – inferring as much as possible from the behaviour of the systems these leaders inhabit.
Wednesday, December 03, 2003
Leadership of Change
Leadership is commonly divided into two types – transactional (maintaining the status quo) and transformational (changing it).
In today’s business world, Transformational Leadership is sometimes accorded higher status than Transactional Leadership. Change is valued for its own sake, and therefore managers who can stimulate, provoke and ride change are going to be the top dogs.
But do we want all our leaders to be Transformational?
In today’s business world, Transformational Leadership is sometimes accorded higher status than Transactional Leadership. Change is valued for its own sake, and therefore managers who can stimulate, provoke and ride change are going to be the top dogs.
But do we want all our leaders to be Transformational?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


